The grade 7/8 class and the Snow Lake students have just recently finished reading the book Half Brother by Kenneth Oppel. After the reading was over, we watched the documentary Project Nim. Project Nim and Half Brother are very similar, but also very different.
Some similarities are both chimps didn’t like the dominant male in the book the dominant male was Richard, in the documentary the dominant male was Herb. Both Zan and Nim were sold to a biomedical lab, both were saved from the biomedical lab. Both were truly loved by one person in the documentary nim only loved Bob, in the book Zan only liked Ben. Both liked to sign hug, but weren’t actually learning language. Both were truly connected to 1 female chimp Zan connected to Rachel, and Nim connected to Lily. All the students were just helping to get extra credit and Herb, and Richard the dominant males didn’t try to help when they were being sold to a biomedical lab. Both loved the kitten.
The differences between the 2 are that the book takes place in British Columbia the documentary took place in New York. Zan was brought into a family with an only child;Nim was brought into a family with 7 children. Nim learned many more signs then Zan did every day, and Nim had to go to school to learn. Zan just got to stay home and learn. Zan was treated much better then Nim was. Nim had to go to school and had no toys to play with or his own bedroom.
Some new information I learned was that even though chimps only grow to be five feet tall they can be five times stronger then a full grown man. I also learned that chimps are social creatures, they can’t be alone in a cage they need a friend.
there are happy things that happened in this documentary. Nim went to a horse ranch instead of a biomedical lab. Henry saved Nim from going to a biomedical lab with Bob’s help. Bob helped Chris Burn get more chimps from the biomedical lab to make Nim happy to have a friend. Nim finally found a chimp friend named Lily who eventually became a mother to Nim’s children. When Bob came back for Nim and everybody started to care for him.

Bobby Chromik
There are some disturbing parts. Herb left Nim and didn’t come back to help him even when he went to the biomedical lab. Nim threw Stephane around like a rag doll and almost killed her. Nim getting poked and prodded in the biomedical lab.
so after reading the book and watching the documentary I have a question Why do we test these products on chimps if there going to be used on humans we aren’t the same so it might have a different affect on us ?








